CARE-WATCH Sept 26, 2020:News from the front lines of LTC


RNAO will continue to call for the Nursing Home Basic Care Guarantee as the only way forward. It will also continue to urge that no nursing home – whether for-profit or not-for-profit – go below four hours of direct nursing and personal care per resident, per 24 hours

The Registered Nurses’ Association of Ontario (RNAO)
divider-line image
divider-line image

The Lead:

COVID-19 and long-term care facilities: Does ownership matter?


  • Research has shown that for-profit ownership of long-term care (LTC) homes has been relevant to patterns of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) outbreaks and deaths in Ontario; this is related to building characteristics and chain status of owners.
  • For-profit ownership has been related to lower LTC staffing levels in research comparing for-profit and nonprofit facilities.
  • Recent research has shown an association between lower nurse staffing levels and worse COVID-19–related outcomes in LTC facilities.
  • Long-term care policy should prioritize funding and mandating sufficient staffing levels based on the available evidence.

In related research, Stall and colleagues examined the relation between ownership of a long-term care (LTC) facility and the occurrence, extent and mortality associated with outbreaks of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) in Ontario’s 623 LTC facilities.1 In their analysis, adjusted at the facility level, the authors found no association between ownership and the odds of an outbreak occurrence. They did find, however, that facilities run on a for-profit basis had more extensive outbreaks and more deaths than facilities run on a nonprofit basis, with an even more marked effect when for-profit facilities were compared with facilities that were entirely municipally run. However, when multi-bed room design was added to the model, for-profit ownership status lost its significance for these outcomes, leading the authors to conclude that building upgrades should be an important part of addressing the problems in the LTC sector in Ontario.

In their expanded model, the authors also found that chain status of the LTC facility conferred a significant risk of more extensive outbreak and deaths. Of Ontario’s for-profit LTC facilities, 85% are part of a chain (v. 31% of nonprofit, and no chains among municipally run homes), which begs the question of whether for-profit chain status of a facility is a significant and independent risk factor for more extensive outbreaks and deaths, even after controlling for multi-bed rooms. If so, simply ensuring building upgrades, while important, is unlikely to be enough to address systemic deficiencies.

Stall and colleagues’ study did not include data on staffing across facility ownership groups. Long-term care staffing is consistently reported in the literature as being an important difference between for-profit, nonprofit and publicly owned facilities. 2,3 A 2011 study of nursing homes in the United States found that the largest for-profit chains had the lowest nursing hours,4 and an earlier Canadian study found that government (health-authority)–owned facilities provided 61 more minutes of staffing per resident day than for-profit facilities.5 A recent report from the Office of the BC Seniors Advocate on government contracts to LTC homes found that the for-profit sector failed to deliver 207 000 hours of care for which it had received funds in 2016/18, compared with the nonprofit sector, which provided 80 000 more hours of care than it was funded to deliver.6 Moreover, research is starting to show that, when it comes to outbreaks of COVID-19, LTC staffing matters..

A recent study of COVID-19 outbreaks in California found that LTC facilities with total staffing levels of registered nurses (RNs) less than the recommended minimum standard (0.75 h per resident day) were twice as likely to have residents with infection of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) than adequately staffed facilities.7 A study in Connecticut found that for LTC facilities with at least 1 confirmed case of COVID-19, every 20-minute (per resident day) increase in RN staffing was associated with 22% fewer confirmed cases, and in facilities with at least 1 death from COVID-19, every 20-minute increase in RN staffing significantly predicted 26% fewer deaths.8

Read More…

divider-line image

Inspired by Carol Wodak founding member of CITIZEN WATCH

BACKGROUNDER: CITIZEN WATCH was created as a public service for the people of Alberta.  It was the work of an ever-widening network of individuals from across the province, including families and friends of long term care and assisted or supportive living residents and those requiring long term care supports in their own homes. CITIZEN WATCH WEBSITE 


INDEX (CLICK on Carol’s contributed collated collections by date)

Aug 24, 2020
Aug 16, 2020Aug 12, 2020Aug 3, 2020
JULY 27. 2020JULY 6,2020JUNE 30, 2020
JUNE 29, 2020JUNE 18, 2020JUNE 17, 2020
May 31, 2020May 29, 2020May 15, 2020


CLICK for Carol’s complete collection of carefully crafted carewatch content
divider-line image